The After-Hours Problem Every Health Plan Pays For But Nobody Talks About

The After-Hours Problem Every Health Plan Pays For But Nobody Talks About

Health plans are spending real money to staff phones that barely ring — because regulators say they have to. There's a better way.

If you run a call center at a health plan, you already know the math does not work on nights and weekends.

CMS requires Medicare Advantage plans to maintain live phone support from 8am to 8pm, Monday through Friday, for six months of the year. During the other six months — open enrollment season,  that requirement extends to seven days a week. A member might call on a Sunday afternoon asking about a prospective plan. Someone has to be there to pick up.

The problem is that almost nobody calls.

Health plan leaders will tell you this plainly. The call volume during these extended windows is minimal. Members are not dialing their insurer at 7pm on a Tuesday or noon on a Sunday. But the chairs still have to be filled. The phones still have to be answered. And the cost of filling those chairs — overtime premiums, staffing incentives, or third-party vendor contracts — is disproportionate to the handful of calls that actually come through.

This is one of the most persistent, quietly expensive operational problems in health insurance. And it is exactly the kind of problem that an AI call center was built to solve.

The Compliance Staffing Trap

The after-hours staffing challenge is a structural one, not a management failure. Health plans that run excellent call centers — the ones with sub-30-second answer times, 87%+ CSAT scores, and turnover rates well below industry average — face the same bind as everyone else when it comes to extended hours.

The core team is built for peak efficiency during business hours. These are the agents who have completed months of training, who know how to navigate thousands of plan variations across multiple lines of business, and who deliver the kind of comprehensive, accurate service that drives member satisfaction and retention. They are an expensive, carefully developed asset.

Asking them to work evenings and weekends is not just a scheduling inconvenience — it means overtime premiums, voluntary staffing models that depend on a few willing employees, and the constant risk that a key person decides they no longer want the Sunday shift. Some health plans have solved this by finding one or two people who prefer non-standard hours. But building an operational model around individual willingness is fragile, and most CX leaders know it.

The alternative, outsourcing after-hours coverage, introduces its own problems. Even the best onshore third-party vendors face a fundamental limitation: they cannot match the depth of knowledge that an in-house team develops over months of training. Health insurance is not a simple lookup environment. A member calling about a prospective Medicare Advantage plan may have questions that require understanding specific benefit structures, provider network nuances, and cost-sharing rules. Third-party agents, no matter how well-intentioned, often end up triaging calls rather than resolving them, taking a message and promising a callback from someone who can actually help.

For health plans that view customer experience as a core competitive differentiator — and many do, this is an unacceptable trade-off. They would rather pay the overtime than risk a subpar member interaction. But they know they are overpaying for what amounts to a handful of calls.

Open Enrollment: When the Quiet Problem Gets Loud

The after-hours challenge intensifies during open enrollment, when CMS  (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) requirements expand to seven-day coverage. Suddenly, the health plan needs agents available on Saturdays and Sundays, not just for existing members with service questions, but for prospective members evaluating plans.

This is a different kind of call. Prospective member inquiries during enrollment are often exploratory: comparing benefits, asking about provider networks, understanding premiums and cost-sharing. These are calls that matter enormously to the business, every one of them is a potential new member, but they arrive unpredictably and in low volume during weekend hours.

The staffing calculus becomes even more strained. You need agents who understand the product well enough to have a consultative conversation with a prospective member. You need them available during hours when your core team would rather be off. And you need enough of them to meet the compliance mandate, even if only three calls come in all day.

Many health plans handle this by offering overtime incentives during the enrollment period and hoping enough people sign up. Some rotate weekend shifts among the team. A few still rely on third-party partners for overflow — but even then, the depth of product knowledge required for a prospective member conversation often means the call gets routed back to a salesperson for a callback on Monday.

Every one of those callbacks is a risk. The prospective member who called on Sunday with buying intent may have moved on by Monday afternoon.

Why This Is an AI Call Center Problem — Not an AI Chatbot Problem

It is worth being precise about what kind of AI solution actually addresses this. Health plans have been pitched chatbots, virtual assistants, and IVR enhancements for years. Most of them solve for the wrong layer of the problem.

A chatbot on the member portal can handle the easy, self-service questions — "What is my copay?" or "Where do I find my ID card?" — but those are the calls that most health plans have already deflected through MyChart, member apps, and online portals. The calls that actually reach the phone line are the ones that self-service could not resolve. They require conversation, context, and often the ability to navigate multiple backend systems simultaneously.

What health plans need for after-hours and enrollment coverage is not a chatbot that deflects. They need an AI call center — one that can pick up the phone, engage in a real conversation, and handle the interaction the way a trained agent would. That means understanding the member's plan, pulling the right information from the right systems, and delivering a complete, accurate response without putting the caller on hold or promising a callback.

"The after-hours problem is a perfect example of where AI call centers deliver immediate, measurable value," says Florent de Goriainoff, CEO and founder of Fluents.ai. "You have a compliance mandate that requires coverage, volume that does not justify the staffing cost, and a quality bar that rules out most outsourcing options. An AI call center handles all three at once — it picks up instantly, it never needs overtime pay, and it delivers consistent service at 2am the same way it does at 2pm."

The Integration Requirement

For an AI call center to work in this environment, it has to operate inside the health plan's existing technology ecosystem — not alongside it. A health plan running TalkDesk for telephony, Epic for member records, and a knowledge management platform for benefit documentation needs the AI to pull from all of those systems in real time, on a live call.

This is where most AI solutions stall. The technology may be capable in isolation, but connecting it to a carrier's actual data environment — the policy administration system, the claims platform, the provider directory — becomes a project that the contact center department neither controls nor can fund. Health plan CX leaders have seen this pattern repeatedly: a promising AI demo followed by months of integration work that never reaches production.

Fluents.ai takes a fundamentally different approach. Rather than handing carriers API documentation and a self-serve setup portal, Fluents builds native integrations with the health plan's existing stack — CRMs like Salesforce, CCaaS platforms like TalkDesk and Five9, and the policy administration and knowledge management tools the team already relies on. The Fluents team works hands-on with each carrier to configure and deploy the AI call center to fit their specific workflows, data structures, and compliance requirements.

"We are not asking health plans to become systems integrators," de Goriainoff says. "Our team builds the integration for them. That is the only way this actually gets to production instead of sitting in a pilot that never launches."

The Real ROI: Eliminating the Waste Without Sacrificing the Experience

The business case for an AI call center covering after-hours and enrollment periods is unusually clean.

On one side, you have the current cost: overtime premiums for agents willing to work non-standard hours, the management overhead of building voluntary staffing rosters, or the vendor fees and quality trade-offs of third-party coverage. These costs are well-understood and easy to quantify.

On the other side, you have an AI call center that handles the same calls at a fraction of the cost, with no ramp-up time, no scheduling complexity, and no quality compromise. It scales effortlessly during enrollment season — from two calls on a quiet Sunday to two hundred on the first weekend of open enrollment — without requiring a single additional hire.

But the value extends beyond cost reduction. The calls that happen during these windows may be few, but they are not unimportant. A Medicare Advantage member calling at 7pm with a question about an upcoming procedure deserves the same quality of service as someone calling at 10am on a Wednesday. A prospective member calling on a Sunday during enrollment deserves a knowledgeable, consultative conversation — not a voicemail box or a callback promise.

For health plans that have built their brand on superior member experience, the AI call center is not a compromise. It is the only way to extend that experience into every hour they are required to operate, without burning out or overpaying the human team that makes it exceptional during business hours.

The Bottom Line

The after-hours staffing problem is one of those operational realities that health plan leaders have accepted as a cost of doing business. CMS says you have to be open. Nobody calls. You pay anyway.

It does not have to work that way.

An AI call center — one that is deeply integrated into the health plan's existing systems, purpose-built for real phone conversations, and backed by a team that handles the implementation — eliminates the trade-off between compliance and cost, between coverage and quality.

The health plans that adopt this approach first will not just save on overtime. They will deliver a consistent member experience across every hour of every day, including the ones where the phones used to ring into an empty room.

​

​

​